“Engaged by the Sea” Beach Theme Cookies
From $60.00Bring a taste of the beach to your next celebration with our beautifully handcrafted…
New Driver Celebration Cookie Set
From $55.00Bring a taste of the beach to your next celebration with our beautifully handcrafted…
Game Day Football Sugar Cookies
From $55.00Celebrate every play in style with our handcrafted Game Day Football Sugar Cookies .…
Signature Bow Collection
From $65.00An elegant engagement-themed sugar cookie set in classic black, white, and gold. The…
Alice in Wonderland cookie set
From $60.00A whimsical Alice in Wonderland cookies set featuring hand-decorated Wonderland…
FC Club Cookies
From $55.00Our FC Club Cookies are handcrafted sugar cookies made for football teams, players, and…
Thirty Flirty and Thriving Cookie Set
From $55.00Celebrate turning 30 in style with our “Thirty, Flirty & Thriving” cookies. These…
Luxury Floral Mother’s Day Cookies
From $65.00Celebrate Mother’s Day with our beautifully handcrafted floral cookies, designed with…
Every Order, Made with Care
Read Our FAQFrom the first idea to the final box, here's what you can count on with every Cozy Sweetery treat — handcrafted just for you, made fresh to order, and packaged with love so it arrives picture-perfect.
Soccer Birthday Celebration Cookie set
From $55.00Soccer Cookies set
Tutti Frutti Cookies
From $55.00Our Fruit & Berry Cookies are handcrafted sugar cookies inspired by fresh…
Congrats grads!Sugar Cookies set
From $55.00Say “congrats!” the sweetest way! These custom sugar cookies showcase graduation…
Class Of 2026! Graduation cookie set.
From $55.00Celebrate your Class of 2026 graduate with a custom set of beautifully decorated sugar…
One American Boy Sugar Cookie Set
From $55.00Celebrate your little one’s first birthday with custom Little All-American Boy sugar…
Two Wild Second Birthday Sugar Cookie Set
From $55.00Our custom Two Wild birthday cookies are handcrafted with premium royal icing and…
One Silly Goose first birthday cookies
From $55.00Celebrate a special first birthday with a charming “One Silly Goose” custom cookie set…
O-Fish-ally Back-to-School Teacher Cookie Gift Set with 2 notepads
From $12.00Make the first day of school extra sweet with this personalized teacher cookie gift set…
Personalized Toy Story Second Birthday Cookie Set
From $55.00Celebrate turning two with a personalized Toy Story–inspired cookie set featuring…
Winnie the Pooh cookie set
From $55.00Hand-drawn Winnie the Pooh cookies in a soft, gender-neutral color palette, perfect for…
Baby Bear cookie set
From $55.00Celebrate a sweet baby boy with this adorable teddy bear baby shower cookie set.…
Birthday Sweet Set
From $180.00A curated set of custom birthday cookies designed around your theme, colors, and age —…
No treats in this collection yet — check back soon!
Follow Us
Cozy Sweetery
Handcrafted treats and coordinated party décor for your perfect celebration. Based in Sarasota, FL.
Let's connect — follow along for new drops, tastings & sweet inspiration.
Get First Access to Presales & New Designs Something Special in Mind?
We love bringing your ideas to life. Whether it's a wedding, baby shower, birthday, or corporate event, our custom treats are made just for you.
Request a Custom OrderMade with Love
Handcrafted with care and attention to detail.
Made to Order
Freshly made just for your special occasion.
Made from Scratch
Baked fresh from scratch — never premade.
Various Flavors
A range of flavors to suit every taste.
Personalized
Add names, monograms, and custom details.
Local Pickup
Sarasota pickup or curbside available.
Shipping Available
Nationwide shipping on select treats.
Gift Packaging
Gift-ready packaging available on request.
You Might Also Love
Signature Bow Collection
From $65.00An elegant engagement-themed sugar cookie set in classic black, white, and gold. The…
Easter Bunny Cookie set
From $55.00Bring a taste of the beach to your next celebration with our beautifully handcrafted…
Birthday Sweet Set
From $180.00A curated set of custom birthday cookies designed around your theme, colors, and age —…
Soccer Birthday Celebration Cookie set
From $55.00Soccer Cookies set