“Engaged by the Sea” Beach Theme Cookies
From $60.00Bring a taste of the beach to your next celebration with our beautifully handcrafted…
New Driver Celebration Cookie Set
From $55.00Bring a taste of the beach to your next celebration with our beautifully handcrafted…
Game Day Football Sugar Cookies
From $55.00Celebrate every play in style with our handcrafted Game Day Football Sugar Cookies .…
Signature Bow Collection
From $65.00An elegant engagement-themed sugar cookie set in classic black, white, and gold. The…
Alice in Wonderland cookie set
From $60.00A whimsical Alice in Wonderland cookies set featuring hand-decorated Wonderland…
Easter Bunny Cookie set
From $55.00Bring a taste of the beach to your next celebration with our beautifully handcrafted…
FC Club Cookies
From $55.00Our FC Club Cookies are handcrafted sugar cookies made for football teams, players, and…
Thirty Flirty and Thriving Cookie Set
From $55.00Celebrate turning 30 in style with our “Thirty, Flirty & Thriving” cookies. These…
Every Order, Made with Care
Read Our FAQFrom the first idea to the final box, here's what you can count on with every Cozy Sweetery treat — handcrafted just for you, made fresh to order, and packaged with love so it arrives picture-perfect.
Luxury Floral Mother’s Day Cookies
From $65.00Celebrate Mother’s Day with our beautifully handcrafted floral cookies, designed with…
Soccer Birthday Celebration Cookie set
From $55.00Soccer Cookies set
Tutti Frutti Cookies
From $55.00Our Fruit & Berry Cookies are handcrafted sugar cookies inspired by fresh…
Congrats grads!Sugar Cookies set
From $55.00Say “congrats!” the sweetest way! These custom sugar cookies showcase graduation…
Class Of 2026! Graduation cookie set.
From $55.00Celebrate your Class of 2026 graduate with a custom set of beautifully decorated sugar…
One American Boy Sugar Cookie Set
From $55.00Celebrate your little one’s first birthday with custom Little All-American Boy sugar…
“Engaged by the Sea” Beach Theme Cookies (Copy)
From $60.00Bring a taste of the beach to your next celebration with our beautifully handcrafted…
Two Wild Second Birthday Sugar Cookie Set
From $55.00Our custom Two Wild birthday cookies are handcrafted with premium royal icing and…
One Silly Goose first birthday cookies
From $55.00Celebrate a special first birthday with a charming “One Silly Goose” custom cookie set…
O-Fish-ally Back-to-School Teacher Cookie Gift Set with 2 notepads
From $12.00Make the first day of school extra sweet with this personalized teacher cookie gift set…
Personalized Toy Story Second Birthday Cookie Set
From $55.00Celebrate turning two with a personalized Toy Story–inspired cookie set featuring…
Winnie the Pooh cookie set
From $55.00Hand-drawn Winnie the Pooh cookies in a soft, gender-neutral color palette, perfect for…
Baby Bear cookie set
From $55.00Celebrate a sweet baby boy with this adorable teddy bear baby shower cookie set.…
Sweetheart Cookie Assortment
From $60.00Indulge in our delightful Sweetheart Cookie Assortment , a charming collection perfect…
Light Blue Baby Shower Floral Design
From $60.00Celebrate the arrival of a little one with our exquisite Light Blue Baby Shower Floral…
Bridal Shower Sugar Cookies
From $55.00Custom bridal shower sugar cookies, made to order in Sarasota, FL.
Whimsical Cookie Wonders in Lavender
From $65.00These wedding-themed cookies are a delightful addition to any celebration. Featuring…
Happily Ever After Cookies
From $55.00Wedding dress and shoes cookies made to order in Sarasota, FL.
Pleats and Letters Round Monogram Cookies
From $49.00These charming small monogram pleated round cookies, approximately 1.5 inches in size,…
Tropical Delight Cookies
From $60.00Bring a taste of paradise to your next celebration with our Tropical Delight Party…
Island Bloom Hibiscus Cookies
From $55.00These delightful Tropical Hibiscus Flower cookies are a vibrant treat for any occasion.…
Western Boo Baby Shower Cookies
From $60.00These delightful cookies bring a playful Halloween twist to your baby shower with…
No treats in this collection yet — check back soon!
Follow Us
Cozy Sweetery
Let's connect — follow along for new drops, tastings & sweet inspiration.
Get First Access to Presales & New Designs Something Special in Mind?
We love bringing your ideas to life. Whether it's a wedding, baby shower, birthday, or corporate event, our custom treats are made just for you.
Request a Custom OrderMade with Love
Handcrafted with care and attention to detail.
Made to Order
Freshly made just for your special occasion.
Made from Scratch
Baked fresh from scratch — never premade.
Various Flavors
A range of flavors to suit every taste.
Personalized
Add names, monograms, and custom details.
Local Pickup
Sarasota pickup or curbside available.
Shipping Available
Nationwide shipping on cookies.
Gift Packaging
Gift-ready packaging available on request.
You Might Also Love
Signature Bow Collection
From $65.00An elegant engagement-themed sugar cookie set in classic black, white, and gold. The…
Sweet Dessert Cups
From $56.00Individual layered dessert cups topped with berries and cream — an elegant, grab-and-go…
Luxury Floral Mother’s Day Cookies
From $65.00Celebrate Mother’s Day with our beautifully handcrafted floral cookies, designed with…
Halloween Cookie Decorating Kit (DIY Set)
From $17.95Perfect for a cozy, creative activity at home—easy, fun, and designed for all ages to…