Decorated Cookies

O-Fish-ally Back-to-School Teacher Cookie Gift Set with 2 notepads

From $12.00

Make the first day of school extra sweet with this personalized teacher cookie gift set featuring colorful fish cookies and a pencil cookie customized with the teacher’s name. Presented with an “O-fish-ally Back to School” 2 notepads, magnet this ready-to-gift set is perfect for a first-day teacher gift, welcome-back surprise, or teacher appreciation treat.

The presale is closing on the August 23rd.

Pickup is on August 25th.

Handcrafted & hand-decorated to order

Made fresh from scratch

Individually package available

Personalized

Pickup in Sarasota, FL — local delivery on request

Shipping available on select treats

FlavorOne flavor per dozen/extra charge per dozen. Use Custom Form for Gluten Free options or request the flavor you don't see.

QuantityMinimum 1 dozen. Available in increments of 6

Quick ReminderOrders require advance notice to ensure availability; rush orders may be limited and subject to additional fees. Our kitchen handles nuts, gluten, eggs, and dairy. Inspiration photos are used as a guide and will not be copied exactly; final designs will reflect a similar style and color palette. Products are made in a Florida cottage food home kitchen and are not inspected by the state. Colors may vary slightly due to screen differences. Final pricing may increase based on design complexity, additional colors, specialty finishes, personalization, or packaging upgrades. in this case a notice will be sent

Personalization / Special Instructions

Order FulfillmentHow would you like to receive the order.

Preferred date

Total: $12.00

Quantity

Made with Love

Baked with care

Custom & Unique

Made just for you

Local Pickup

Easy & convenient

Carefully Packaged

Perfect for gifting

Hand Decorated

Sweet details

Soft Bite

Delicious & soft

Personalized

Your vision, our treats

Planning a party?

We can create a sweet table that brings your theme to life.

Get a Custom Quote

O-Fish-ally Back-to-School Teacher Cookie Gift Set with 2 notepads

Choose your date

September 2026

Made with Love

Custom & Unique

Local Pickup

Carefully Packaged

Hand Decorated

Soft Bite

Personalized

You May Also Love

Soccer Birthday Celebration Cookie set

Congrats grads!Sugar Cookies set

Class Of 2026! Graduation cookie set.

Meringue Pops on a Stick – Custom Color Meringue Lollipops

Planning a party?

Cozy Sweetery