Halloween Cookie Decorating Kit (DIY Set)
From $17.95Perfect for a cozy, creative activity at home—easy, fun, and designed for all ages to…
“Engaged by the Sea” Beach Theme Cookies
From $60.00Bring a taste of the beach to your next celebration with our beautifully handcrafted…
Meringue Pops on a Stick – Custom Color Meringue Lollipops
From $39.00Custom meringue pops on a stick made fresh to match your celebration theme. These light…
Meringue Tower
From $60.00Bring a light, delicious touch to your celebration with our custom meringue pops! These…
Mini Decorative Cakecicles Disney inspired.
From $39.99What do you get when a cake and a popsicle fall in love? Cakesicles! Our custom mini…
Handcrafted Cake Pops
From $35.98Classic cake pops featuring a smooth chocolate coating and soft, moist cake center,…
Busy Bee Custom Celebration Cake
From $70.00The cake is covered in soft yellow buttercream with a lightly textured, rustic finish.…
Simple Elegance: tiered cake
From $160.00Need a cake that says "I'm a big deal"? Our two-tier cakes are perfect for celebrations…
Every Order, Made with Care
Read Our FAQFrom the first idea to the final box, here's what you can count on with every Cozy Sweetery treat — handcrafted just for you, made fresh to order, and packaged with love so it arrives picture-perfect.
Custom Black&White Bow Bridal Sweets Collection
From $205.00A chic black and white dessert collection inspired by bows and the perfect knot.…
New Driver Celebration Cookie Set
From $55.00Bring a taste of the beach to your next celebration with our beautifully handcrafted…
Game Day Football Sugar Cookies
From $55.00Celebrate every play in style with our handcrafted Game Day Football Sugar Cookies .…
Delicate Florals Custom 2-Tiered Cake
From $160.00Elegant two-tier birthday cake with smooth ivory buttercream and modern horizontal…
Unicorn Package
From $135.00A colorful half-and-half rainbow cake paired with coordinated decorated sugar cookies.…
Carousel Cake fondant decoration
From $383.00An elegant two-tier celebration cake perfect for a Christening, Baby Shower, or…
Vintage Labubu inspired cake with cakepop fondant figurines.
From $120.00A buttercream-covered vintage cake featuring intricate ruffles, swags, and piped…
Signature Bow Collection
From $65.00An elegant engagement-themed sugar cookie set in classic black, white, and gold. The…
Alice in Wonderland cookie set
From $60.00A whimsical Alice in Wonderland cookies set featuring hand-decorated Wonderland…
Meringue Bouquet, Edible Flowers easy to share. GF.
From $40.00A handcrafted meringue bouquet made from Swiss-style meringue, piped onto sticks and…
Little Princess Birthday Package.
From $339.00Little Princess Dessert Package A coordinated princess-themed dessert set featuring…
Meringue Hearts on a Stick
From $45.00Custom meringue pops on a stick made fresh to match your celebration theme. These light…
Easter Bunny Cookie set
From $55.00Bring a taste of the beach to your next celebration with our beautifully handcrafted…
FC Club Cookies
From $55.00Our FC Club Cookies are handcrafted sugar cookies made for football teams, players, and…
Thirty Flirty and Thriving Cookie Set
From $55.00Celebrate turning 30 in style with our “Thirty, Flirty & Thriving” cookies. These…
Luxury Floral Mother’s Day Cookies
From $65.00Celebrate Mother’s Day with our beautifully handcrafted floral cookies, designed with…
Soccer Birthday Celebration Cookie set
From $55.00Soccer Cookies set
Tutti Frutti Cookies
From $55.00Our Fruit & Berry Cookies are handcrafted sugar cookies inspired by fresh…
Congrats grads!Sugar Cookies set
From $55.00Say “congrats!” the sweetest way! These custom sugar cookies showcase graduation…
Class Of 2026! Graduation cookie set.
From $55.00Celebrate your Class of 2026 graduate with a custom set of beautifully decorated sugar…
One American Boy Sugar Cookie Set
From $55.00Celebrate your little one’s first birthday with custom Little All-American Boy sugar…
“Engaged by the Sea” Beach Theme Cookies (Copy)
From $60.00Bring a taste of the beach to your next celebration with our beautifully handcrafted…
Two Wild Second Birthday Sugar Cookie Set
From $55.00Our custom Two Wild birthday cookies are handcrafted with premium royal icing and…
12 Floral Cupcakes set
From $50.00Bright floral cupcakes decorated with hand-piped buttercream flowers in rich magenta,…
One Silly Goose first birthday cookies
From $55.00Celebrate a special first birthday with a charming “One Silly Goose” custom cookie set…
O-Fish-ally Back-to-School Teacher Cookie Gift Set with 2 notepads
From $12.00Make the first day of school extra sweet with this personalized teacher cookie gift set…
Personalized Toy Story Second Birthday Cookie Set
From $55.00Celebrate turning two with a personalized Toy Story–inspired cookie set featuring…
Winnie the Pooh cookie set
From $55.00Hand-drawn Winnie the Pooh cookies in a soft, gender-neutral color palette, perfect for…
School Ready cookie set (DIY)
From $17.99Create your own back-to-school treats with this fun DIY Cookie Decorating Kit! Each…
Baby Bear cookie set
From $55.00Celebrate a sweet baby boy with this adorable teddy bear baby shower cookie set.…
Floral Cupcakes in a box
From $50.00A beautiful dozen floral cupcakes decorated with hand-piped buttercream roses and…
Tropical Hibiscus Ruffle Cake
From $125.00A romantic ruffle cake finished with delicate hand-piped blooms in our signature…
Dipped Berry Treats
From $42.00An assortment of chocolate-dipped treats — cookies, pretzels, and more — drizzled and…
Sweet Dessert Cups
From $56.00Individual layered dessert cups topped with berries and cream — an elegant, grab-and-go…
Garden Party Cake
From $160.00A garden-inspired celebration cake adorned with hand-crafted florals — made to order…
Princess Party DIY Cookie Set
From $15.99Decorate, create, and enjoy! Our DIY Cookie Decorating Kits include freshly baked sugar…
Sweetheart Cookie Assortment
From $60.00Indulge in our delightful Sweetheart Cookie Assortment , a charming collection perfect…
Light Blue Baby Shower Floral Design
From $60.00Celebrate the arrival of a little one with our exquisite Light Blue Baby Shower Floral…
Elegant Dress Sugar Cookieswer
From $55.00Charming dress-themed sugar cookies, made to order in Sarasota, FL.
Bridal Shower Sugar Cookies
From $55.00Custom bridal shower sugar cookies, made to order in Sarasota, FL.
Whimsical Cookie Wonders in Lavender
From $65.00These wedding-themed cookies are a delightful addition to any celebration. Featuring…
Happily Ever After Cookies
From $55.00Wedding dress and shoes cookies made to order in Sarasota, FL.
Pleats and Letters Round Monogram Cookies
From $49.00These charming small monogram pleated round cookies, approximately 1.5 inches in size,…
Tropical Delight Cookies
From $60.00Bring a taste of paradise to your next celebration with our Tropical Delight Party…
Sweet Initials Party Set
From $80.00These delightful cake pops feature charming monograms, perfect for baby showers or any…
Tropical Hibiscus Bliss Party
Price by requestOur Hibiscus Bliss Party Cookies bring a splash of tropical charm to your celebrations.…
Island Bloom Hibiscus Cookies
From $55.00These delightful Tropical Hibiscus Flower cookies are a vibrant treat for any occasion.…
Tea Time Floral Cookies
From $55.00Dozen of these charming Floral Cup Cookies are a sweet way to show love and…
Pumpkin Patch Thanksgiving or Halloween Cupcakes
From $40.00These delightful Thanksgiving cupcakes are a festive addition to your holiday table.…
Swirl of Joy Birthday Cupcakes
From $36.00These Swirl Of Joy Birthday Cupcakes are a delightful treat for any celebration. Each…
Decorative Swirl Cupcakes
From $48.00Indulge in the delightful charm of our Decorative Swirl Cupcakes, where every bite is a…
Floral Fantasy Cupcake Arrangement
From $68.00Transform your celebrations into a whimsical wonderland with our stunning Floral…
12 Garden Party Floral Cupcakes
From $50.00Bring a touch of whimsy and elegance to your next gathering with our delightful Garden…
Ckristamas floral arrangement cupcake
From $60.00Introducing our delightful Christamas floral arrangement cupcake , where festive cheer…
Western Boo Baby Shower Cookies
From $60.00These delightful cookies bring a playful Halloween twist to your baby shower with…
3 sets of Boo-tiful DIY Cookies
From $45.00Dive into Halloween fun with our Spooky Fun DIY Cookies set! This delightful kit…
Mini Spookies Presale
From $9.99🎃 Order by Tue Oct 20 → pickup Thu Oct 29 / Fri Oct 30 No minimum at $9.99/set 6 sets…
Boo-tiful DIY Cookies (presale)
From $15.00🎃 Order by Tue Oct 20 → pickup Thu Oct 29 / Fri Oct 30 No minimum at $15.99/set 6 sets…
No treats in this collection yet — check back soon!
Follow Us
Cozy Sweetery
Let's connect — follow along for new drops, tastings & sweet inspiration.
Get First Access to Presales & New Designs Something Special in Mind?
We love bringing your ideas to life. Whether it's a wedding, baby shower, birthday, or corporate event, our custom treats are made just for you.
Request a Custom OrderMade with Love
Handcrafted with care and attention to detail.
Made to Order
Freshly made just for your special occasion.
Made from Scratch
Baked fresh from scratch — never premade.
Various Flavors
A range of flavors to suit every taste.
Personalized
Add names, monograms, and custom details.
Local Pickup
Sarasota pickup or curbside available.
Shipping Available
Nationwide shipping on cookies.
Gift Packaging
Gift-ready packaging available on request.
You Might Also Love
Vintage Labubu inspired cake with cakepop fondant figurines.
From $120.00A buttercream-covered vintage cake featuring intricate ruffles, swags, and piped…
Sweet Dessert Cups
From $56.00Individual layered dessert cups topped with berries and cream — an elegant, grab-and-go…
Halloween Cookie Decorating Kit (DIY Set)
From $17.95Perfect for a cozy, creative activity at home—easy, fun, and designed for all ages to…
Signature Bow Collection
From $65.00An elegant engagement-themed sugar cookie set in classic black, white, and gold. The…