Handcrafted in SarasotaCustom orders now bookingCookies Ship NationwideCustom TreatsCookies Ship Nationwide
Browse by:
Berry Bloom Ruffle CakeHibiscus Sugar CookiesDipped Berry TreatsSweet Dessert CupsBirthday Sweet SetGarden Party Cake
Decorated CookiesCakesDipped TreatsParty PackagesDIY SetsPresaleCake PopsMeringuesCupcakes
BirthdayBaby ShowerWeddingReligiousGraduationGender RevealBridal ShowerHolidayMother's DayEasterSportDIYSchoolHalloween
BoyGirlAdults
PredesignedCustom Design
HomeShopOur MenuParty GuideGalleryFor BakersFree Baking Tools
Cookie CuttersSoon
Baker GuidesSoon
AboutReviewsFAQContactCustom OrderSearch
Berry Bloom Ruffle CakeHibiscus Sugar CookiesDipped Berry TreatsSweet Dessert CupsBirthday Sweet SetGarden Party Cake
Decorated CookiesCakesDipped TreatsParty PackagesDIY SetsPresaleCake PopsMeringuesCupcakes
BirthdayBaby ShowerWeddingReligiousGraduationGender RevealBridal ShowerHolidayMother's DayEasterSportDIYSchoolHalloween
BoyGirlAdults
PredesignedCustom Design
Sweetheart Cookie Assortment
Sweetheart Cookie AssortmentSweetheart Cookie AssortmentSweetheart Cookie AssortmentSweetheart Cookie AssortmentSweetheart Cookie AssortmentSweetheart Cookie AssortmentSweetheart Cookie AssortmentSweetheart Cookie Assortment
Decorated Cookies

Sweetheart Cookie Assortment

Home›Shop›Decorated Cookies›Sweetheart Cookie Assortment
From $60.00

Indulge in our delightful Sweetheart Cookie Assortment, a charming collection perfect for celebrating love, friendship, or simply treating yourself! Each cookie is handcrafted with the finest ingredients, ensuring a burst of flavor in every bite. Choose from a variety of scrumptious flavors, including classic vanilla, rich chocolate, and zesty lemon, all beautifully decorated to match your desired theme.

Whether you're planning an intimate gathering, a festive event, or a special surprise, these customizable cookies are sure to impress. Select your favorite colors and designs to create a unique assortment that reflects your style. Our Sweetheart Cookie Assortment is a delightful way to add a touch of sweetness to any celebration!

Handcrafted & hand-decorated to order
Made fresh from scratch
Individually package available
Personalized
Pickup in Sarasota, FL — local delivery on request
Nationwide shipping on cookies
One flavor per dozen/extra charge per dozen. Use Custom Form for Gluten Free options or request the flavor you don't see.
Minimum 1 dozen. Available in increments of 6
Quick Reminder
Orders require advance notice to ensure availability; rush orders may be limited and subject to additional fees.Our kitchen handles nuts, gluten, eggs, and dairy.Inspiration photos are used as a guide and will not be copied exactly; final designs will reflect a similar style and color palette.Products are made in a Florida cottage food home kitchen and are not inspected by the state.Colors may vary slightly due to screen differences.Final pricing may increase based on design complexity, additional colors, specialty finishes, personalization, or packaging upgrades. in this case a notice will be sent
Choose option for each cookie in the set.
How your cookies are boxed. Keep in mind order fulfillment like shipping or pickup, reason for the order, like gifting or serving. Use Custom Form for additional requests.
Not sure how many to order?Our Party Guide has cake sizes, servings, and treat quantities for every event.Open the Party Guide →
Ordering more than one treat? Say so here and we will keep everything together for the same date. Have a look at the full menu to add more items.
How would you like to receive the order.
Total: $62.00

Made with Love

Baked with care

Custom & Unique

Made just for you

Local Pickup

Easy & convenient

Carefully Packaged

Perfect for gifting

Hand Decorated

Sweet details

Soft Bite

Delicious & soft

Personalized

Your vision, our treats

You May Also Love

Signature Bow Collection
Decorated Cookies

Signature Bow Collection

From $65.00
Alice in Wonderland cookie set
Decorated Cookies

Alice in Wonderland cookie set

From $60.00
Meringue Bouquet, Edible Flowers easy to share. GF.
Dipped Treats

Meringue Bouquet, Edible Flowers easy to share. GF.

From $40.00
“Engaged by the Sea” Beach Theme Cookies
Decorated Cookies

“Engaged by the Sea” Beach Theme Cookies

From $60.00

Planning a party?

We can create a sweet table that brings your theme to life.

Get a Custom Quote
Planning a party? Our Party Guide covers how much to order, cutting the cake, care & getting it home safely.Read the Party Guide

Let's connect — follow along for new drops, tastings & sweet inspiration.

Get First Access to Presales & New Designs